Best Test 11 be4 60s and after 60s
*India best eleven vs india best eleven*
( Yes before 60s and after 60s the best eleven has chosen by me and imaginary review about their Test match fight )
* Before 60s 11:-
1. Vijay Merchant
2.Vinu Mankad
3.Vijay Hazare
4.Pali Umrigar
5. Vijay Manjrekar
6.Farukh Engineer
7. Lala Amarnath
8.Amar Singh
9.Mohammed Nisar
10.Bapu Nadkarni
11. Subhash Gupte
* After 60s the 11:-
1.Sunil Gavaskar
2.Virendra Sehwag
3.Rahul Dravid
4. Sachin Tendulkar
5.Mohinder Amarnath
6.Mahendra Singh Dhoni
7.Kapil Dev
8.Jawagal Shree Nath
9. R Ashvin
10. Bhishan Bedi
11. B Chndrashekhar
* I have chosen my best eleven of two different era. And I have placed the biggies of their time who have left their remarkable presence and some are in the action.
*Note-
There are many great names have left but you know I had to place only eleven. So players like Virat Kohali, Dilip Vengsarkar, VVS Laxman , A Prasanna , Shri Niwas Venkat Ragwan, Zahir Khan , Mohammed Azharuddin, Ekanath Solkar, Nawab Patodi, Mustaq Ahamad,
Harbhajan Singh , S Kirmani , S Patil, Yashpal Sharma, Ck Nayadu , Jasu Patel ,Chandu Borde , Salim Durrani, Sourabh Ganguli, etc.
Yes each person has its own perception and concept and according to it he has its favourites and best ones. But yes apart from it to remind and evaluate all the person has to give place in the squad when the matter of the best eleven.
*Yes these are the players whose data or statics speak the story of their greatness and class and the cricket fraternity salutes them ever.
*Yes if these two giants clash in the Test what would happen difficult to say but according to my view the team before 60s
Will win the series yes by 3-2.
*Comparison between greats :
Openers :
1. Merchant vs Gavaskar
Yes here both are master of opening batting and in my sense Vijay Merchant leads a bit
Yes 100-99 point
2.V Mankar vs V Sehwag
Yes undoubtedly here Vinu seems far ahead
than Virender Sehwag
Why????
Because of great technique and temperament and against tough wicket and tough bowling attack and Captain like Lala Amarnath who was so strategic and intelligent his technique is tested indeed Viru could be thirst even for 30s while he has 2 triple and one just 6 short to triple. The duo of M.Nisar-Amarsingh was genuine fast bowlers and also quality ones and against this kind of pacers and
Spin wizard as Lala Amarnath, Vinu Mankad, Subhash Gupte , Bapu Nadkarni were such a trapper and sure enticed the flamboyant Virender. According to my view he didn’t test fully and when tested he remained failure. So point here 100-30
3. VHazare vs R Dravid
Though technology both are equal but Vijay Hazare is leeading here because the legend Don Bradman showered his praise on his class batting . He was contemporary to Don and his record is emphatic and had power to carry match to victory singlehandedly while Rahul Dravid didn’t have such a morale like Vijay Hazare.
So here point ratio 100- 40
4. Here this place due have terrefic record Sachin seems giant but it is well said that the figures not say true story ever so I don’t underestimate Poly Umarigar he was the most rocking batsman before Gavaskar and Vishwanath and the highest run gettor of his time from indian test batting arena.
So proportion rests 100-80
5. V Manjrekar vs M Amarnath
Yes here 49-51 being all rounder Jimmi lead a bit
6. F Engineer vs Dhoni
Here Farukh leads yes by ratio 60-40 yes because of the Test Farukh who remained opener and much sound batsman than M Dhoni . Dhoni is fragile than Farukh in Keeping wicket so in Wicket keeping 49-51
7. Yeah great to discuss this slot
Both the captained of indian side.
*In captaincy Lala was great
*In batting field Lala Amarnath is bigger than Kapil
*But as a bowler
Difficult to compare
Because one is spinner and other is the speedster
And both are master in their bowling field
But Kapil being the pacer
leads than Lala so point margin is 50-50
8.Amar Singh was so quick than J Shrinath
And ability to bowl 145 plus up to long spell so
Here Shrinath trail yes by point 20-80
9.Mohammed Nisar vs R Ashwin
Here as the genuine pacer M Nisar leads and he was so quick up to 10 beginning overs and tested batsmen and in his first spell could scalp 2 or 3 big wickets but as a batsman just hitter of unpredictable while R Ashwin a genuine spinner and good batsman so 50-50
10.Bapu Nadkarni vs Bishan Bedi
Yes Bapu Nadkarni who has prolific record of most thrifty bowling of era and was bigger bowler though I don’t underestimate B Bedi
So 50-50 point
11. Subhash Gupte vs B Chandrashekhar
Yes the critics consider Shane Warne’s delivery is the delivery of the century but any critics not agree and Subhash Gupte’s s delivery bowled to great G Sobers is greater than S Warne.
*Conclusion: Mostly my query and evaluation is basis on all the facts particularly the tough situation before 60s and after 60 the situation was tougher but after 90 got easier due to protected , banned and restricted cricket and due to fixing snare.
* Ultimately the post of the captain is post dignified as well as the challenging because the victory and defeat always accredited to him. His all decisions are always matter .
So who should be the skipper from both the unique sides.
First of all do name this giant imaginary teams.
Yes Lala Amarnath 11 and MS Dhoni 11
Why Dhoni I have chosen as captain because he is the lone captain who awarded top position in all the three formats and has so successive record of winning Test than any presented in the squad. Though as Sunny ,Kapil., Bedi ,Dravid ,Sachin are the big cricketers but mr Cool is forfeited for the captain than all.
*One another fact I want to deliver captaincy to great Vijay Hazare from before 60s and same cadre biggies Sunny Gavaskar I want to make the captain from after 70s.
*NK sevak “sanatan”